All-Star thoughts: Lohse, Nathan
Posted on July 1st, 2008 – 11:22 AMBy Joe Christensen
Kyle Lohse improved to 10-2 with a 3.67 ERA for the Cardinals last night. Is he an All-Star? We’ll find out when the rosters are announced Sunday.
As Boston manager Terry Francona mulls over his AL roster, I have a suggestion: No matter how many AL closers are deserving, Joe Nathan should be there.
Sounds like a no-brainer, but this could be a dilemma. Here’s a look at the AL’s top closers:
Pitcher (Saves/Opportunities, ERA)
Francisco Rodriguez (32/34, 2.04)
George Sherrill (26/32, 3.68)
Jonathan Papelbon (24/28, 2.00)
Mariano Rivera (22/22, 0.74)
Joe Nathan (22/24, 1.34)
Joakim Soria (22/23, 1.25)
Bobby Jenks (18/21, 1.95)
The Twins are positioned strongly enough in the standings to justify multiple All-Star selections. Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau and Joe Nathan all should get in.
Mauer is leading the voting at catcher, and deservedly so. Morneau trails Kevin Youkilis at first base, which shouldn’t be a problem because Morneau is the only other AL first baseman putting up All-Star numbers. (Pete D is right, Jason Giambi, too.)
Nathan’s situation is stickier because it’s tough to make a case for other Royals, beyond Soria, or other Orioles, beyond Sherrill. Remember, every team gets at least one selection.
K-Rod, Rivera and Papelbon are locks. Pap has blown four saves, but Francona is going to stick with his guys.
I think Francona should buck tradition and stockpile closers instead of starters. Who would you rather see pitch the fifth inning of a tie game, Nathan or … Mike Mussina? Here are the basic numbers of some of the top AL starters:
Pitcher (W-L, ERA)
Cliff Lee (11-1, 2.34)
Joe Saunders (11-4, 3.06)
Mike Mussina (10-6, 3.87)
Vicente Padilla (10-4, 4.13)
Daisuke Matsuzaka (9-1, 3.21)
Roy Halladay (9-6, 2.90)
Ervin Santana (9-3, 3.32)
Gavin Floyd (9-4, 3.45)
Andy Pettitte (9-5, 3.98)
Justin Duchscherer (8-5, 1.91 - Owen is right, bad omission there)
John Lackey (6-1, 1.44, after starting year on the DL)
That’s a pretty underwhelming list. Lee should get the start. After that, I’d take Dice-K, Halladay, Lackey, two or three others, and load up on closers.
After all, the All-Star Game “counts” now, at least for home-field advantage in the World Series. Most pitchers will be throwing one inning anyway. Might as well go with the league’s strengths and take Nathan, the ultimate one-inning specialist.
