Al Franken

Reaction to Franken’s tax problems

Tuesday, April 29th, 2008

Our story about Franken’s disclosure that he’s paying about $70,000 in back taxes and penalties resulted in plenty of comments being posted to the story, which you can read here.

Also, here’s a sampling of reaction from bloggers — first those on the right, and then those on the left.1Franken0430.jpg

Hugh Hewitt on Townhall.com says:

“There’s no other way to put it. Franken cheated on his taxes and has been found out. … How many working class Democrats are going to leave a wealthy-comedian tax dodger for a very effective, classy Norm Coleman? I think quite a few.”

Ed Morrissey at Hot Air doesn’t think Franken was deliberately trying to evade taxes. But Morrissey’s point is something Franken no doubt will be hearing plenty of from critics who give him the benefit of the doubt:

“Did Franken intend to evade his tax responsibilities? I’d say it’s much more likely that he just didn’t care enough to figure out what they were, although he certainly knew enough to incorporate to gain legitimate tax advantages. Now he wants Minnesotans to believe that he cares about their concerns when he didn’t care enough about his own business to run it properly. The voters — and taxpayers — of Minnesota are not going to have much affection for someone who has more in common with Leona Helmsley than with themselves.”

Sean Hackbarth — formerly of the Fred Thompson presidential campaign — writes on The American Mind: “Ah, tossing the accountant under the bus. At least it was his grandmother. [I think Hackbarth must have meant “wasn’t his grandmother.”] We don’t know if this will be the final shoe to drop. Judging from the mismanagement of Franken’s campaign a place like Puerto Rico could come calling demanding him to pay up.”

At Power Line, Scott Johnson writes: “Since the expiration of the Al Franken decade in 1990, the only kind of humor for which Franken has been responsible is unintentional. Assuming Franken’s tax delinquencies are the result of negligence, they would run true to his post-Franken decade form.”

Minneapolis blogger doubtcreptintohisvoice doesn’t think this will derail Franken’s campaign, but he nevertheless finds it troubling: “While the figure and scale is big, the Franken people are implying that it stems from the same misunderstanding of tax law. They continue to blame the accounting firm. It could very well be that the accounting firm is incompetent and gave horribly faulty advice. But the very fact that Franken was unable to figure out about himself what the Republicans uncovered fairly easily is troubling. This will probably not foil Franken’s DFL endorsement, but it can’t help.”

At MnPublius, Matt Martin argues that the facts point to no intent on Franken’s part, and he praises the Franken campaign for getting on top of these financial problems:

First of all, if the Frankens paid taxes on every single cent earned, then this truly isn’t an issue of tax evasion; I mean, why go through the bother of paying at all then? It seems that the sum gain Franken occurred due to the relative tax rates was about $4000; not enough to be worth this trouble. In short, it seems that this is legitimately an accounting error and that’s not just clever spin.

Second, the states aren’t the ones asking for money. This isn’t a story that the GOP had their hands on, it’s something that the campaign started researching when the accountant’s prior mistakes were realized. They did the research, and now the Frankens are willfully correcting the mistake by repaying the taxes owed to the various states; in some cases this is as little as $53.

I’m not going to sugar-coat this, all these issues have made for some rough times for the Franken campaign over the last month, but I can honestly say that this step by the campaign is encouraging. The campaign seems to be at the front of this now and has decided to take the path of full, willful disclosure–a choice that will hopefully get this all out there.

Likewise, Joe Bodell at Minnesota Campaign Report posted this item at 9:48 p.m. (Tuesday), giving Franken’s campaign credit for the damage control effort: “Got off the phone with Franken campaign staffer Andy Barr a little while ago. The campaign office is busy, obviously, but not doing what one might think they’d be doing at a time like this. According to Barr, their goal was to call every single DFL State Convention delegate so the delegates ‘could hear what really happened from us tonight before they got it wrong from someone else tomorrow.’ It’s damage control mode, no doubt about it, but there’s a good way to do that and there’s a bad way, and Franken’s team appears to be doing it the good way.”

So, what do you think of Franken’s problems, and what do they mean for his campaign?

Franken delivers ‘major speech’ outlining Senate campaign

Tuesday, March 25th, 2008

Al Franken, the Democratic U.S. Senate candidate, held a rally in the State Captiol Rotunda this morning and delivered what his campaign calls a “major speech defining the issues of this campaign.”

Here is the full text of Franken’s prepared remarks. (Tomorrow, Republican Sen. Norm Coleman kicks off his reelection campaign.)

First of all, I’d like to thank all of you who are standing here with me in this beautiful room for standing with me in this important fight.

And if any of you haven’t met Franni yet, please meet my secret weapon. And if this secret’s out, meet the next one, my daughter Thomasin.

Something is happening all over this state. You saw it on Caucus Night, when over 215,000 DFLers showed up to say they’re ready for a new direction, even if it means they have to hang out in a hot, crowded room for a few hours.

And you’re seeing it here today.

I am so proud to have the endorsement of 65 state legislators, representing districts all over the state, from here in the Twin Cities, to the suburbs, to Greater Minnesota. And, as a member of four labor unions myself, I’m incredibly proud to be endorsed by 16 labor unions, representing over 250,000 members and retirees, as well as their families.

These men and women, and the working families they represent, are partners in building a new progressive majority.

And we know what we want.

We want universal health care.

We want an economy that works for everyone, not just the special interests.

We want to address global warming and create “green” jobs in renewable energy and energy efficiency.

We want a world-class education for all our kids so that they can compete in the 21st century economy.

And we want to restore our standing in the world, starting with getting out of Iraq and bringing our troops home.

And when George W. Bush leaves office on January 20, 2009, we want his enablers to go with him ­ starting with Norm Coleman.

You know, throughout this campaign we’re going to be talking about Norm Coleman’s habit of saying one thing and doing another.

But when it comes to his record of being a rubber-stamp for President Bush, we can’t say he didn’t tell us so.

Six months after Paul Wellstone died, Norm Coleman did an interview with Roll Call. Leaning back in his chair and waving around an unlit cigar, he told the reporter, “To be very blunt, and God watch over Paul’s soul, I’m a 99% improvement over Paul Wellstone.”

When he apologized, he told us that what he really meant was that he was a 99% improvement over Paul Wellstone ­ in terms of supporting this White House.

And he meant it. In his first year, when President Bush’s approval ratings were high, he voted with the President 98% of the time.

He was a cheerleader for the war in Iraq, and even to this day continues to support the Bush policy of endless war.

He continues to support the Bush economic plan of irresponsible tax cuts for the wealthy, and even wants to make those tax cuts permanent.

As the Minnesota co-chair of Bush’s 2004 re-election campaign, he was an attack dog, serving as a member of Karl Rove’s “truth squad,” leading the Star Tribune to write that he had “demeaned the U.S. Senate and embarrassed many of his constituents.”

He called President Bush “God’s answer” to our prayers. And he wasn’t even being satirical.

This President has turned our federal government into a fully-owned-and-operated division of the Republican Party.

Last week, the Secretary of Education was dispatched to St. Paul, on the taxpayers’ dime, to stand with Norm Coleman and proudly announce a new pilot program ­ that will have absolutely nothing to do with the state of Minnesota. I guess that means they’re taking us seriously.

Even worse, this President has handed the keys to Washington over to the special interests.

Five years ago, Norm Coleman was given the amazing opportunity to serve the people of Minnesota in the Senate. But instead, he sold out to those same special interests.

Senator Coleman has received hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from defense contractors, oil companies, insurance companies, and pharmaceutical companies.

And these were good investments…for them.

After cashing checks from Halliburton, Senator Coleman fell down on the job as chairman of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations while waste, fraud, and abuse sabotaged the re-construction of Iraq.

After cashing checks from Big Oil, Senator Coleman voted to give the oil companies billions of dollars in tax subsidies that they didn’t need and we can’t afford.

After cashing checks from the pharmaceutical and insurance industries, Coleman voted to prohibit Medicare from negotiating with drug companies for lower prices on prescriptions, costing seniors and taxpayers billions of dollars.

George W. Bush may be leaving office, but these special interests aren’t going anywhere without a fight.

So, it’s not enough that we take back the White House. It’s not even enough that we take more seats in Congress. We have to take back this government. We have to tell the special interests that they’re not so special anymore. We have to elect people who will stand up to the oil companies, stand up to the drug companies, stand up to the insurance industry, and stand up for the working families of this state.

This week, Senator Coleman is kicking off his re-election campaign with what he’s calling the “Bringing Minnesota Together” Tour.

Ironically, it seems that Senator Coleman is going to spend most of the “Bringing Minnesota Together” Tour attacking me.

But it won’t work, because the people of Minnesota understand the very simple decision they have to make: Did they really send Norm Coleman to Washington to be a rubber-stamp for the special interests, and can they really afford to give him six more years to keep doing it?

And I think if Senator Coleman is going to be “Bringing Minnesota Together,” he ought to bring the facts with him. Because, believe me, we know that Norm Coleman is going to try to re-write his record. That’s the only way he’ll have a chance to win. And are we going to let him do that?

No. We’re going to hold Norm Coleman accountable for what he’s done in the U.S. Senate. Because while he’s been in Washington, the people of Minnesota have indeed been brought together. George W. Bush and Norm Coleman have taken this country in the wrong direction ­ and they’ve taken all of us with them.

You don’t have to be sick to feel the impact of our broken health care system. We spend twice as much on health care per capita as any other industrialized country, and yet we’re ranked 37th in the world in outcomes. Every other industrialized country covers 100% of its citizens, but we’ve seen the number of uninsured balloon to 47 million, with tens of millions more who are underinsured and go to bed every night fearing that they’re just one health crisis away from bankruptcy. Fifty percent of all bankruptcies in this country are the result of a health crisis. They don’t have that in other countries.

And Minnesotans should know that their Senator, Norm Coleman, voted against allowing people forced into bankruptcy because of high medical costs to protect their homes.

You don’t have to be poor to feel the effects of the Republican Recession. In the last nine months, homeowners have lost nearly a quarter trillion dollars in home equity. Household income is stagnant, the job market is tanking, and middle-class families are feeling the squeeze from all sides.

You don’t have to be a parent to understand that we are leaving too many children behind. I haven’t met a teacher in this state who doesn’t believe in accountability ­ and I haven’t met a teacher who thinks No Child Left Behind is working. Whether it’s the narrowing of our curriculum, overcrowded classrooms, or the chronic under-funding of special education, our public schools need help, and they’re not getting it from Washington.

You don’t have to be a college student to know that the cost of higher education has skyrocketed to unacceptable levels. I met one student at MSU-Mankato who told me he works fulltime and sells his plasma twice a week to make tuition payments. And more often than not, when I tell that story around the state, someone in the audience nods and says, I know someone who does that, too.

You don’t have to be a veteran to know the cost of this war. Fifty-nine Minnesotans have lost their lives since we invaded Iraq a little over five years ago. Nearly five hundred have been wounded. In the towns they left to serve our country, countless neighbors, friends, and families have sacrificed. And all of us know the damage that this war has done to our economy, and to our standing in the world.

You don’t have to be progressive to recognize that there is nothing conservative about the movement conservatives that have held power in this country over the past seven years. There’s nothing conservative about misleading us into a war. There’s nothing conservative about running up huge deficits year after year. There’s nothing conservative about spying on Americans without warrants. And there’s nothing conservative about torture. I have to tell you, I never knew there were so many former Republicans until I started this campaign.

And, you know what, you don’t have to be a Democrat to want real change in Washington. No matter whether you’re a Democrat, a Republican, an Independent, or someone who’s never even thought about what party you might belong to, we welcome you to join this campaign.

Last October, I went on a ten-college tour. Some of the kids I met with were 11 years old when this President took office. They don’t remember that the federal government is supposed to work. They’ve seen Katrina. They’ve seen Iraq. And even sadder, they don’t remember that we were once the most respected country on the face of the planet.

After all, we are the country that sent a man to the moon, the country that mapped the human genome, the country that beat fascism and communism, the country that re-built Europe after World War II and still had enough juice left over to invent rock and roll and the Internet.

And I believe we can restore that greatness.

Instead of arguing over whether or not global warming really exists, we can turn this crisis into a tremendous opportunity by investing in renewable energy and energy efficient technologies. We can preserve our environment, improve our national security, end our dependence on foreign oil, reinvigorate our manufacturing sector, and create high-tech, high-paying jobs right here in Minnesota ­ all at the same time.

Instead of watching our jobs flow overseas, we can have a trade policy that encourages a race to the top, not a race to the bottom. I will not support any trade agreement that doesn’t have strong, enforceable labor, environmental, and safety standards. And here at home, I’ll proudly co-sponsor the Employee Free Choice Act, vote to raise the minimum wage, and work hard to make pensions more secure, because a hard day’s work deserves a decent day’s pay, and a lifetime of hard work deserves a secure and comfortable retirement.

Instead of the ironically-named No Child Left Behind, we can have great public schools for every American child ­ schools like the ones in St. Louis Park that helped my older brother to get into MIT and me to get into Harvard, becoming the first in our family to attend college. Schools with class sizes small enough, and curricula broad enough, to allow our teachers to develop the next generation of brilliant Americans instead of simply teaching them how to take a test.

Instead of being last in the industrialized world in preventive health care, instead of bankrupting our families and our nation with escalating health care costs, we can have universal health care and join the community of nations that covers every citizen.

Instead of shortchanging our veterans, we can honor their service and their sacrifice by making sure they get the benefits they’ve earned. I’ll fight to fully fund the VA so that every vet can have access to full physical, mental, and long-term care for life, and I’ll support a new G.I. Bill to renew the commitment we made to our vets over half a century ago.

Instead of continuing to lose billions of dollars a month and more precious American lives every day in Iraq, we can end this war, quickly and responsibly, and bring our troops home.

And after seven years of the Bush-Coleman economy driving us into a deep economic hole, we can finally stop digging.

Instead of more tax cuts for the wealthiest one percent, we can direct tax relief where it’s actually needed.

Instead of helping millionaire CEOs send their kids to Europe for the summer, we can help middle-class families send their kids to college in the fall by extending and expanding the tuition tax credit.

Instead of just bailing out Bear Stearns, we can help the family in Stearns County in danger of losing their home by implementing a moratorium on foreclosures.

Instead of just thinking about the next quarter, we can think about the next quarter century. We can end the Bush War on Science, and make permanent the research and development tax credit, so that the next great idea comes from right here in Minnesota. We can invest in early childhood education, to give every child a fair chance to succeed in this new century. And we can replace our cowboy foreign policy with one that engages our allies and addresses global challenges, instead of just responding to threats.

We have a lot of work to do together. But it starts by deciding that we are going to have a new direction in this country. We’re going to have a government that truly belongs to us. We’re going to have another chance in our lifetimes to restore America’s greatness.

I believe it more strongly every day. Paul Wellstone said, “The future belongs to those who are passionate and work hard.” I am so passionate about what we can achieve together. Are you ready to work hard alongside me?

It has been, and will continue to be, my privilege to work alongside you.

Thank you.

Coleman to launch reelection campaign

Monday, March 24th, 2008

Until now, Sen. Norm Coleman has waged a reelection campaign remotely — mostly through press releases and Web videos. This week, he takes to the streets.

On Wednesday, Coleman officially launches his campaign with a rally, followed by a three-day tour around the state and another day attending GOP congressional district conventions.

Not willing to cede the spotlight, Democrat Al Franken announced this morning that on Tuesday he’ll hold a rally, announce “exciting new endorsements and deliver a major speech defining the issues of this campaign.” That event will be in the State Capitol Rotunda at 10:30 a.m.

The Coleman tour begins at his campaign headquarters, 680 Transfer Rd., St Paul, at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday. Later in the day he stops in Rochester, Duluth and Moorhead. Thursday’s schedule brings him to Fergus Falls, Alexandria and St. Cloud. On Friday, he make six stops — in Shakopee, St. Peter, Mankato, Waseca, Owatonna and Albert Lea. (The time and location of each stop can be found in the Coming Up feature on Politically Connected, www.startribune.com/politics.

On Saturday, he attends congressional district endorsing coventions in Albert Lea (First District), Northfield (Second District) and Hibbing (Eighth District).

The other major candidate in the race, Democrat Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer, has a Friday night event on his public schedule — holding a campaign house party in Minneapolis. (Details in Coming Up.)

‘This is now a two person race’

Monday, March 10th, 2008

On Friday, Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer’s campaign sent out a three-exclamation-point press release headlined: “Thanks to you, this is now a two person race!!!”

The release claimed that Nelson-Pallmeyer had “surpassed Mike Ciresi in delegate support.” It cited a local DFL convention Duluth, and gave the delegate-selection results as Nelson-Pallmeyer 10, Al Franken 10 and Ciresi 2.

Jack_Nelson_Pallmeyer_at_house_party.jpgThe DFL doesn’t track delegates at this stage of the U.S. Senate race — between the precinct caucuses and the state endorsing convention in June — so there’s no way to measure delegates statewide. But anecdotal reports were confirming the essence of Nelson-Pallmeyer’s point: Ciresi was struggling.

This afternoon, Ciresi abandoned the race, issuing a press release that barely addressed why he made the decision. This passage was the only comment on that point: “In my judgment, continuing the endorsement race would only lead to an unnecessary floor fight. It is time to step aside.”

Now, it really is a two-person race. (There are a couple other candidates who aren’t a factor).

Franken clearly is — and always has been — the frontrunner. He has raised $5.2 million for his campaign, compared with $284,000 for Nelson-Pallmeyer. Franken has already run television commercials, and he enjoys high name recognition by virtue of his celebrity status. However, he also has a high unfavorable rating.

Nelson-Pallmeyer was a late entrant, only announcing his candidacy in October. He has run an energetic campaign, has impressed debate audiences and can point to a passionate group of supporters.

Usually, when it comes to describing a candidate’s supporters, “passionate” is code for “small.”

Is that the case with Nelson-Pallmeyer?

Compared to Franken, Nelson-Pallmeyer certainly lacks the nationwide network of financial contributors. Closer to home, Nelson-Pallmeyer is coming up short in key union endorsements, compared with Franken, who has the backing of labor groups ranging from teachers to public employees to steelworkers to teamsters.

We’ve seen in the past, though, that Minnesota’s process of selecting convention delegates through the precinct caucus system opens the door wide open to the right grassroots candidate.

Is Nelson-Pallmeyer that candidate?

Or you could get him a tie

Friday, December 14th, 2007

This priceless political fundraising pitch was forwarded to me by colleague Howard Sinker.

It’s an e-mail from Gayle Kagen, wife of Wisconsin Democratic Congressman Steve Kagen: “I’m so proud of my husband…Steve’s 58th birthday is this week. It would be a wonderful gift for Steve to see how many people are behind him and want to keep him in Congress by sending a birthday donation to his re-election campaign fund.”

Don’t you think Steve would be just as touched if you sent him a tie, or even a musical greeting card? And by the way, don’t breathe a word of this to him; I’m sure Gayle thought this up and sent out the e-mail all by herself.

You’ll be happy to know that, if you send a check, Gayle will allow you to do this, too: “You can also include a note of thanks with your donation if you wish.”

While I’m at it, here’s a snippet from a recent fundraising appeal from Republican Sen. Norm Coleman, who relies on the tried and true approach of hoping to cash in by raising the spectre of his opponent — Democrat Al Franken — actually winning:

“You see, Franken is trying to clean up his act. Reinvent himself. He’s cut down on the profanity. Instead of cussing out Republicans he now calls for bipartisanship. Instead of crude jokes about political opponents, he talks civility.

“Liberal donors from across the country get the joke. They know that, if elected, the venomous, deeply partisan Al Franken they know and love will come out on the floor of the U.S. Senate.”

If you have fundraising e-mails or letters that you’re particularly fond of, by all means share them here — or send them to me as the campaign wears on. You can e-mail them to PoliticallyConnected@startribune.com, or mail them to:

Dennis McGrath
Editor, Politically Connected
Minneapolis Star Tribune
425 Portland Ave.
Minneapolis, MN. 55488

Senate race a dead heat

Monday, November 5th, 2007

A new poll shows Sen. Norm Coleman in a dead heat with Al Franken and Mike Ciresi, the two leading Democratic candidates.

Here’s the poll, taken by SurveyUSA for Roll Call, a Capitol Hill newspaper.

The poll has Coleman at 46 percent when matched against Franken, who has 45 percent. Against Ciresi, Coleman gets 44 percent and Ciresi gets 44 percent.

Other hightlights:

The favorable ratings for all three candidates are low. Coleman’s favorable and unfavorable ratings are about even; Franken’s unfavorables are much higher than his favorables; and Ciresi is still struggling to make himself known.

The gender gap is significant. Coleman runs 11 points better among men than among women vs. Franken. And Coleman runs 15 points better among men than women vs. Ciresi.

Here’s a look back at the Star Tribune’s Minnesota Poll taken in September, which included Coleman job approval and candidate image questions, but no horse-race questions.

Senate race: the bloggers’ view

Thursday, November 1st, 2007

Minnesota’s U.S. Senate race is being watched closely by many outside Minnesota. Here’s a look at what bloggers beyond our borders are saying.

Al Franken

Al_Franken_mug.jpg
Al Franken

The Texas Liberal blog reports from inside Franken’s fundraiser in Houston recently. Besides recounting what Franken had to say — he described himself as the likely DFL nominee; he’ll fight aggressively against negative attacks; and he likes meeting people — Texas Liberal tells how to get into a $500 fundraiser for a mere $50.

Brendan Nyhan takes Franken to task for suggesting that the government levy fines for lying on the airwaves, arguing that Franken’s position would silence speech and target political minorities.

This link on Propeller.com — to a recent story in The Nation – led to a lively exchange, with views on Franken ranging from he’ll lose because he projects an air of intellectual superiority to he’ll have so much hilarious material to work with as a senator that he’ll make C-SPAN worth watching.

Norm Coleman
Coleman’s vote in committee Wednesday against the Law of the Sea treaty landed him in some blogs yesterday. The Citizens for Global Solutions pointed out in a blog posting that of the four “no” votes, “the biggest surprise was Coleman, who voted in favor of the treaty in 2004.” It goes on to say that “substance means little to Coleman, who was John Bolton’s strongest supporter in confirmation hearings during the last Congress.” The treaty is opposed by some who argue that it cedes U.S. sovereignty to the United Nations and an international commission.

Norm_Coleman_2.jpg
Sen. Norm Coleman

THE TYGRRRR EXPRESS reports on Coleman’s recent speech to the Republican Jewish Coalition in Washington and includes this tribute to him: “Whether it is the War on Terror or a collapsing bridge, Norm Coleman gets the big picture. His toughness is mixed with a significant amount of warmth. He is a genuinely kind man, and he was truly beloved in the room.” The blogger also offers Coleman a line he can use that equates Democrats with Minnesota Vikings on a party boat. Coleman laughs (but I don’t think you’ll be hearing Coleman use the line himself).

Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer
Nelson-Pallmeyer got a plug in the Citizens for Global Solutions blog posting about the Law of the Sea Treaty (see above). It added an update to the item about Coleman, noting that Nelson-Pallmeyer “is the first of Coleman’s challengers out of the gate to point out this massive and as-yet-unexplained flip flop.”

Nelson-Pallmeyer also earned a mention in the Lonely Candidate, which tracks instances in which candidates who claim to be the only one who (fill-in-the-blank). It cited this quote from Nelson-Pallmeyer: “I’m the only candidate in this race who has a hyphenated last name.”

Jack_Nelson_Pallmeyer.jpg
Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer

Mike Ciresi
Ciresi received a passing plug in a Rhode Island’s Future blog item about Franken appearing at the Blue State Coffee shop in Providence. Matt Jerzyk says, “I actually like the other Democrat in the race - Mike Ciresi - as much as Franken.” That’s as far as the praise goes, but there you have it.

Ciresi_better_mug.jpg
Mike Ciresi

On Daily Kos, The Big E writes about how the Iraq war is playing in the race. Ciresi has been jabbing at Franken for supporting the war at the outset. The Big E shoot back that while Ciresi opposed the war at the outset, he didn’t do much to act on his opposition. He adds: “Which leads me to one critical point about Mike Ciresi in comparison to Al Franken. Ciresi hasn’t done much in the last five years.”

Jim Cohen
Cohen is another Democratic challenger, but when he shows up in non-Minnesota blogs, the posting is not about him. He’s just mentioned as another candidate. If anyone knows of non-Minnesota posts about him, please add them.

Open skulduggery in Senate race

Thursday, October 25th, 2007

A blog posting about Al Franken campaign appearances offers a peek into the spying that politicos routinely conduct on each other — completely above board.

This headline appears (as of this moment) on the Politically Connected page for Al Franken, where we draw in the latest news stories and blog postings about the candidate: “MN GOP “TRACKER” DENIED ADMISSION TO PUBLIC EVENTS OF AL FRANKEN.”

Al_Franken_mug.jpg
Al Franken

The post is from Minnesota Democrats Exposed (MDE), and it said that the Republican operative who follows Al Franken around at public events has been “denied access to numerous public events where Al Franken is scheduled to appear.”

The post, by Michael Brodkorb, explains that this is a common practice by both parties. He links to a previous posting he did, noting that “J.D. from Franken’s campaign” attended and videotaped a recent Republican press conference critical of Franken.

The campaigns routinely send operatives — sometimes volunteers, sometimes paid staffers — to their opponent’s events. Videocam in hand, they capture every utterance — and every slip of the tongue — and the “highlights” are sure to show up in TV ads down the road.

The campaigns even get to know the tracker assigned to them.

Franken’s campaign refers to one GOP operative that followed the Democrat this summer as “Tracker Pete.” But Tracker Pete is now back at school in Duluth, said Franken spokesman Andy Barr.

“J.P. is the new guy,” Barr said.

“J.P. and some other people,” Republican Party spokesman Mark Drake added helpfully.

“This is the game, it’s politics. It happens on both sides of the aisle,” agreed Kelly Schwinghammer, the DFL Party communications director.

The GOP’s Drake, asked about the posting on MDE, cited three instances when the GOP tracker was turned away: A labor-union event in which Franken worked alongside a health care worker for a day; a luncheon; and an appearance before the Macalester College Democrats.

Drake acknowledged that the Franken campaign may not have directly organized and controlled all the events. But he said that Franken’s appearance at them was publicly advertised, including in at least one case on Franken’s website, giving it the imprint of a Franken campaign event. He said that if Franken’s campaign is committed to openness, it should have taken “one minute” in advance to “work with the organizers to allow admission to Republicans.”

Norm_Coleman_2.jpg
Sen. Norm Coleman

Barr said he’s not aware of a single time the Franken campaign has turned a tracker away from an event they had control over, and said that trackers are welcome at their events. He said that Drake was setting an “unreasonable standard” in expecting the Franken campaign to instruct organizers to admit trackers to events that Franken is simply invited to himself.

The DFL’s Schwinghammer said that their trackers have been turned away from a handful of events involving Sen. Norm Coleman, since they started tracking him in August.

The MDE posting drew an interesting comment from Jason, who wrote: “I was at a DFL event. A person, from the GOP I guess, was there with a video camera. This person was younger and seemed naive and inexperienced. She was asked nicely to leave and she did. She probably didn’t have to legally but she did anyway. Does this mean she was ‘denied’ access? Or was she simply too timid?”

Barr, from the Franken campaign, extened this courtsey to the GOP’s Drake. The luncheon event that the tracker was denied access to was videotaped, and the Franken website has a link to it on its home page.

“If Mark needs the link, I’ll be happy to send it to him.”

No need for that. Here it is.

What standards should apply to how campaigns handle trackers? Are there otherwise public events that they should be banned from?

A new Pig’s Eye Podcast

Monday, October 22nd, 2007

We’ve posted a new Pig’s Eye Podcast this morning, which you can listen to here.

Bachmann_victory_party.jpg
Bachmann on Election Night

In this podcast, we discuss:

Mike Ciresi escalating his criticism of Al Franken for being a late convert to opposing the Iraq war. You can read Pat Lopez’s story about this change of tone in the U.S. Senate race here. And you can join a discussion on the issue at The Big Question blog here.

Whether Michele Bachmann made a strategic error by asking TV stations to pull an ad critical of her over the children’s health insurance program. Here’s Kevin Diaz’s story about the flap. Also, there’s been a lively discussion in a posting I did on the controversy last week, asking whether the ad was fair or not. Here’s the post.

Iowa Republicans’ decision to move their caucuses up to Jan. 3, when voters will have barely recovered from New Years Eve celebrations, and when the campaigns will have to find a way to get people’s attention during the holiday season. Here’s our story when the new date was announced.

Left’s money advantage evident in Minnesota

Monday, October 15th, 2007
Al_Franken_mug.jpg
Al Franken

Even before today’s official deadline for federal candidates to report their fundraising numbers, one thing is abundantly clear: the left is raking in big money.

That’s true nationally and it’s the case in Minnesota, too.

Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Al Franken is enjoying being on the receiving end of this leftist largess.

Meanwhile, Sen. Norm Coleman and U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann, both Republicans, are on the receiving end of the spending by leftist groups. They’re both the targets of new television or radio ads critizing them over Iraq (Coleman) and the children’s health insurance battle (Bachmann).

The advantage the left is enjoying is highlighted at OpenSecrets.org, which tracks political money. The OpenSecrets overview is here. From the presidential race to Senate and House races to issue-oriented groups, the left comes out on top.

Norm_Coleman_2.jpg
Norm Coleman

Consider:

Democratic presidential candidates raised an average of $2.2 million to the Republicans’ $1.2 million.

The top two Democrats – Hillary Rodham Clinton and Barack Obama — raised a combined $122 million. The top Republicans — Mitt Romney and Rudy Giuliani — raised $80 million.

Nine out of 10 of the top overall donors have given more than half their money in 2007 to Democrats.

However you slice it, the Democrats end up with the biggest piece of the pie.

And that money is flowing into Minnesota in a big way. OpenSecrets ranks the Minnesota Senate race as the second most expensive in the nation. The Texas Senate race ranked first with $18.5 million raised by the candidates combined, and Minnesota followed close behind with $16.2 million. A distant third was Massachusetts with $8.2 million.

In the most recent quarter, Franken, the Democratic challenger, achieved the rare feat of outraising the incumbent, Coleman. Here’s the Star Tribune story about Franken and Coleman’s fundraising, and here’s our story about money raised by Mike Ciresi.
The radio ad aimed at Coleman is the work of Keeping America’s Promise, which is Sen. John Kerry’s political action committee. Coleman is one of six Republican senators targeted. You can find out more about Kerry’s effort here. And here is Coleman’s campaign website and here is the page we’ve created about him here on Politically Connected.

Michele_Bachman_official_photo.jpg
Michele Bachmann

While Coleman is being hit by a well-known figure, Bachmann is in the sights of a group that isn’t a household name, but it is one of the biggest left-leaning money groups — the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), with 1.9 million members. The SEIU is part of the coalition paying for the TV ads pressing Bachmann to vote later this week to override President Bush’s veto of the children’s health insurance program.

The SEIU’s advocacy arm (a 527 organization), has raised more money than any other 527 group this election cycle, with $6.7 million, according to OpenSecrets. The closest right wing 527 group: GOPAC with $3.7 million. Here’s SEIU’s website and here’s Bachmann’s campaign website and here’s GOPAC’s site.

OpenSecrets cites the fact that Democrats control Congress as a key reason for their fundraising advantage.

Do you think that explains what’s happening? And why do you think the Minnesota Senate race is drawing so much money?